5 COACHES ON THE HOTSEAT
Phil Fulmer, Tennessee
Sometimes coaches hang on just a bit to long and end up destroying something that took them years to build. Bobby Bowden, Joe Paterno, Al Davis and Phil Fulmer come to mind. It’s not that the game has passed him by, he was never much of a brilliant football mind to begin with. The situation in Knoxville has become stale and untenable. What is needed there is new blood and energy. Why Fulmer got a huge extension prior to the season is beyond me. Now the UT boosters are going to have to pony up even more money to get rid of Phil. Plus the economic effect on those Krispy Kreme franchises nearest to the Knoxville campus could be devastating.
Tyrone Willingham, Washington
The schedule looked like a recipe for disaster this year. Willingham was under pressure to deliver and this year’s slate graciously provided him with a non-conference slate of Brigham Young, Oklahoma, and Notre Dame. Plus they began the season facing Oregon back when the Ducks actually had some healthy quarterbacks. It looks like fate and the AD conspired against Ty who I believe has upgraded the talent up in Seattle.
Sylvester Croom, Mississippi State
What made Croom such a great story last year is in part that he was an old school guy who managed to win with defense and conservative play. Unfortunately, it seemed a fluke at the time and looks to be even more of a fluke when compared with this year. Every once in a while the ball bounces your way. The defense looks to be pretty good but Croom has proved you can’t win with just one facet of the game. And you cannot create a truly dominant defense with the talent you can lure into Starkville. The honeymoon is over and whether Croom leaves this year or next the bottom line is the same, MSU is 4-5 years away from being a contender in the SEC.
Bill Stewart, West Virginia
Oh my, West Virginia University athletics. Is this department run by rednecks and morons? Anyone who has been to a WVU game will admit they are the worst, most obnoxious and physically violent fanbase around. Bill Stewart seems like a really nice guy and the kind of person you’d love to have as a neighbor but let’s face it . . . he’s NOT a Division 1 football coach. Not even a Division 1-AA if you look at his past record. The mountaineers were faced at a crossroads with their program when replacing Rich Rodriguez. In basketball they took a risk and hired Bobby Huggins to replace John Beilein. In football they needed to make a similar risk as the University is not a top tier school and cannot compete with other programs on equal footing. They needed a brilliant and exceptional coach if the school wanted to continue their current success. Instead they hired scooter’s grandpa and will soon be irrelevant once again (oh wait . . . it’s already happening this year!)
Tommy Bowden, Clemson
I’ll hand it to Tommy Bowden, he does two things really well. He can recruit and he manages to keep his job despite a severe lack of accomplishment. The Clemson fans do not see themselves as a mediocre, second tier program but if you look at Bowden’s record that’s what they have become and somehow . . . the hope of something better just down the road . . . has kept Bowden in control. If 2nd place is first loser then Clemson is typically the 3rd to 5th loser every year. Because of the long tenure without any championships or major bowls the fanbase is becoming impatient. Still, if you had to bet on Tommy bet on him to hang on a while longer.
Dishonorable Mention: Greg Schiano, Rutgers
Schiano seemed to accomplish the impossible by making Rutgers an almost relevant national program. There was gradual improvement and the talent pool seemed to be getting deeper every year. It looked like Greg was building up a program that could compete every year. Well this year the wheels have fallen off. An 0-3 start has damaged much of the goodwill the Scarlet Knights have built up in their last three bowl seasons. Of course this is the first year Rutgers started off playing against actual FBS caliber teams thinking they were at the point where they could compete with their counterparts around the country. That has been proven to be false. Still, Schiano is a very good coach and I expect them to rebound to 6 or 7 wins and perhaps even make another bowl. Besides, who is Rutgers going to get who is any better than Schiano? Exactly.
All But Gone: Greg Robinson, Syracuse
What can you say about Syracuse? I think they are far and away the most embarrassing team in FBS. I’m not sure exactly why Robinson is even still at Syracuse to be honest? It’s not like they have been any good in his first 3 seasons. But if you are Syracuse University you have to ask yourself . . . who can we get that’s any better? With the awful college following up in New York State, being an annual doormat cannot be good for the health of the program. This change can’t come soon enough.
5 COACHES ON THE RISE
Paul Johnson, Georgia Tech
What can you say about Paul Johnson, how did so many schools let him waste his time at Navy for so many years? Oh that’s right; the establishment looked down upon his triple option offense and decided to promote lesser coaches instead. Well Johnson finally got the opportunity he wanted at a bigger FBS program. The uniqueness of his offense ensures he can compete against even more talented teams because of the difficulty in preparation. It’s hard to imagine how much improvement this team will show in subsequent years when the players in his program become more familiar and comfortable in this system. Look out ACC. (more…)